Teacher and student experiences with Math Magic: a qualitative study

Last updated October 28, 2026

This is the full plan for our qualitative study, including research questions, methods, interview and focus group guides, analysis plan, and consent forms. Bracketed fields should be filled in by the research lead before use. Print or save this page as a PDF to share with your district.

1. Purpose and research questions

This study explores how middle school teachers and students experience Math Magic and what benefits, barriers, and improvements they see. It is designed to understand experiences, not to measure effectiveness.

2. Study design

A qualitative descriptive study using semi-structured teacher interviews, student focus groups, and open-ended survey responses, analyzed with reflexive thematic analysis. Data sources are triangulated: teacher interviews, student focus groups, and anonymous open-ended survey responses collected in the app.

3. Setting and participants

4. Approvals, consent, and voluntary participation

5. Data collection timeline

6. Teacher interview guide (semi-structured)

Follow-up probes: “Can you tell me more?” “Can you give an example?” “How did students respond?”

7. Student focus group guide

Opening script: “Thanks for helping us. There are no right or wrong answers, and nothing you say affects your grade. We want to know what Math Magic is really like for you, including what you don't like. You can skip any question or stop at any time. Please use first names only and keep what others say here private.”

8. Analysis plan

Transcripts and open-ended survey responses will be analyzed using reflexive thematic analysis (Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), 77–101.).

9. Trustworthiness

10. Data protection

11. Limitations

Form A: Teacher consent

You are invited to take part in a study about teachers' and students' experiences with Math Magic. You will be asked to take part in one 30–45 minute interview, which will be audio-recorded with your permission, and you may complete a short anonymous survey. Participation is voluntary and will not affect your employment, evaluation, or access to Math Magic. You may skip questions or withdraw at any time. Your name will not appear in any report.

Questions? Contact: [Research lead name, email, phone].

Form B: Parent/guardian permission

Your child's math class uses Math Magic, an online math practice program. We are doing a study to learn what students think about it. With your permission, your child may join one small-group conversation (25–30 minutes, 3–5 students) during a time that does not take away from instruction, and may answer a short anonymous survey in the app. The conversation will be audio-recorded so we can remember what was said; recordings are deleted after they are typed up. Your child's name will never appear in any report.

Taking part is completely voluntary. It will not affect your child's grades. Your child may stop at any time, and you may withdraw permission at any time by contacting the teacher. Students who don't take part continue normal class activities.

Questions? Contact: [Research lead name, email, phone] or your child's teacher.

Form C: Student assent script (read aloud)

“We're trying to learn what students think about Math Magic so we can make it better. If you want to help, you'll talk with a few classmates and me for about 25 minutes. I'll record us so I don't forget what you said, but I won't use your name when I write about it. There are no right or wrong answers, and it won't change your grade. You can skip any question or stop any time, and nobody will be upset. Your family already said it's okay, but it's your choice too. Do you want to take part?”